Showing posts with label Movie criticism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Movie criticism. Show all posts

Friday, June 26, 2015

The Worst Criticisms You Can Make About Movies (Or Any Entertainment)

Look, guys – I used to be kind of annoying about movies. When I was in my teens and even my early 20s, I think I tended too often to be an asshole when talking about movies. I brought up things I hated a lot; too much, even. I would start discussions and often rant about terrible movies just as often as I'd talk about good ones, and it put some people off. Now, from my own perspective, I was just having fun and being frank and honest. I never looked down on people for what they liked – I was adamant about this – but I also never quite considered exactly everyone else's feelings all the time, either.

I think it's a common thing for young people in our entertainment age, in this time where we're so saturated with 80s and 90s culture and retro referencing and childhood nostalgia and – yes – new good movies coming out. We tend to get sucked into that and get way too passionate about it. It's good to love movies and TV, but we also shouldn't stop caring about other people, and about making the discussion good rather than just honest. I will never stop being honest about what I like and what I don't like, but at the same time, the older I get, I am learning that maybe it's okay to scale back things a bit in favor of having a good, mature discussion.

With that, I'd like to talk about some bad criticisms and arguments I always see when talking about movies. I've done some of them myself over the years, and if you have too, I wouldn't look badly upon you. But I think it's worth making this post anyway, just to promote healthier, better discussions about the entertainment we all love and cherish.

And maybe, just maybe, this is also kind of a rambling soul-searching monologue...a manifesto of thoughts built up over years and years of watching movies, thinking about movies, and thinking about opinions on movies. Maybe these questions and thoughts have been in the corner of my mind all along when writing this blog.

So bear with me. Here we go.

“It's a sellout!”
It's really fucking easy to decry things for being sellouts. Usually, these complaints are leveled by teenagers who haven't yet gone out into the world, or just zealous weirdos mad that their favorite thing has changed. If something sucks, it sucks – I get that. But complaining about something being made for money just seems so ridiculous to me now that I am out in the world trying to make something of myself. Why wouldn't you want something to make money?

If it's a real shameless corporate shill, I get hating that – like Jaws 3 trying to ride Sea World's dick. But even that isn't worth manufactured outrage. Very few things really are. I really only get mad at a movie now if it promotes some kind of horrible idea, or represents humanity poorly. Just being a silly corporate product is a reason for light mockery, but not real rage.

But someone making a movie and making money off it, and getting bigger, isn't really a bad thing in and of itself – people need to make money, no matter what they do; regardless of whether or not you wanted your favorite movie to be an uncompromising, singular work of art made in a vacuum. Yeah, I really want my works of art to be pure. And by that I mean, I want my works of art to be produced by starving, depressed people who pay their rent each month by lending their landlord cigarettes or booze.

“That's just your opinion!”
Of course it's my opinion. I'm the one saying it. I guess people sometimes take certain ways opinions are delivered to be some sort of attack on them personally. When really, if we wanted to do that, there are probably a lot better ways to do so then making fun of a movie they like. If you're the type of person to get offended at someone talking about how they didn't like a movie you liked, you probably have a lot of other things we can make fun of you about.

But seriously – people tend to say this one because they feel attacked and emotional when someone doesn't like their favorite show or movie. It's just a natural response at times, and we have the luxury of feeling that way because our world has become so advanced, because society has progressed as far as it has. We don't have to hunt for food anymore, nor find shelter for fire. We have time to think about this stuff, even if it isn't as important as we think it is. (And it's really not, for the most part - it's still just entertainment at the end of the day.)

I hope nobody actually thinks their opinion is a stone-cold fact. I've certainly never seen anyone who thinks so. I hope the people on the other side of the argument don't expect everyone to just coddle them forever and sugarcoat everything, because that doesn't make for a good discussion either.

There has to be some middle ground, you know? There has to be a way that we can talk frankly, honestly, but also with compassion and understanding. I'm still trying to find it.

“It was just x, y and z – nothing else!”
Not one I see all the time, but now and again I do come across it – people trying to boil down a movie they didn't get to “it was just this and that.” Like for example, if you didn't like The Fault in Our Stars, you might have used this to say “it was just two kids with cancer crying and stuff.”

Well, no...it was a lot more than that, actually.

I dunno. You're certainly allowed to THINK it was just those things (as not everyone has to like a movie that's received well) – but I think that means you just didn't get it. Saying it was just x, y and z is kind of tantamount to admitting you didn't get it, just using more aggressive and self-favoring words.

And I know, I know. That makes me sound like some kind of hipster douche. Well, let me tell YOU...I am exactly that. There's no illusion here, folks.

But also, not “getting” something isn't really the end of the world. It just means it wasn't for you. People see different things in different movies, but nobody ever makes a piece of art that is “just” anything. If you only see the surface elements of the story or find it boring, well, you just didn't get it. Oftentimes, people say something was “too slow” or “nothing was happening,” and oftentimes, I watch whatever it is and really enjoy it. The other people just didn't get it.

And that's okay.

Not everything with tastes in entertainment has to be a pissing contest. We can change our opinions of things as we get older and have different perspectives on the world. It's okay. Not everything we think at one point in time has to stay ironclad and firm all throughout our lives. It would be insane – and also very boring – if we couldn't change how we felt and learn and grow. Not everyone has to get everything at the same time you do, or at all.

I don't get what people like about James Wan's movies, or Nicolas Winding Refn's – but you know, I get it, apparently some people find merit in that stuff, some qualities I can't see. That's fine. It doesn't mean I have to say those movies are anything but absolute shit, because that's what they are to me. I can talk about what I don't like about them and you can say why you do. Perception is a bitch.

“But you liked x, how can you not like y?”
I see this shit all over the place. You say you didn't like something, then some idiot has to chip in and go 'hey, you liked this other thing, why don't you like this too?' Like, hey, you liked snorting crack cocaine! Why don't you also like smashing priceless sculptures to pieces and snorting that? You must just be delusional.” It just sets up this precedent where the other person has to defend their choice for no reason, and you bringing it up seems to just serve the purpose of making you feel smarter and better over something trivial. Just accept the fact that not everything people like always syncs up perfectly.

“The only people who would like this are [some negative stereotype]!”
Don't do this one. You don't know why anybody likes anything, and if you do this, you're pretty much just perpetuating garbage stereotypes as much as that bully you hated in school did. Remember that kid? Who would shove your head in a toilet like it was a football at the touchdown line? Yeah – that guy. It's just poor form to assume anything about someone because of what entertainment they like. People are too complex for that.

“You were just expecting Shakespeare!”
I've talked about this before, but it's another bad, bad argument. When someone doesn't like, say, The Expendables, or whatever crap-ass action or horror movie that came out last month, this is inevitably trotted out. “Well, you can't expect a Shakespearean tragedy...” Or “well, it's not an Oscar-winning drama, it's not supposed to be!” Or the opposite – when someone doesn't like arthouse movies like Dogville or anything David Lynch has done, some people go “well, you must just like Michael Bay action movie jizzsplosion fests!”

Yeah, buddy, when I walked into fucking Tree of Life, I was totally disappointed when it didn't have a musclebound action hero shooting terrorists. That killed the buzz. Thanks for the insight, Freud.

Don't get me wrong, there is some small degree of truth there: you should take into account what a movie was trying to do. If it's a straightforward, dialogue-light movie like Mad Max: Fury Road, yeah, maybe you shouldn't bitch and complain that it's got no long rambling monologues. Little things like that, yeah, clearly the film was trying to do something completely different. If it didn't work for you, fine, but attacking it from some faulty perspective doesn't make sense. I guess if you want to go ahead and do it, that's cool, but I've always been a proponent of the school of thought that you should look at something for what it was trying to do, not what you expected it to be.

I'm just saying come the fuck on, I wasn't expecting Shakespearean tragedy when I watched Insidious 3 last week, but that doesn't make the movie any better for me.

Conclusions
I said earlier that entertainment wasn't as important as we thought it was. I'd like to clarify that a bit, as it is important; don't get me wrong. From a cultural standpoint, movies and other entertainment are very influential and show us important things about the time period and environment they were released in. 

But I do think these last few decades have seen a marked rise in people really, really getting into entertainment on a deeply personal level. Different upbringings and social climates also influence what we like, and as such, people are bound to get very passionate about the movies and books they like, and want to defend them. That's why I think we tend to see all these ad hominems and argumentative tactics used. Because people see their movies and entertainment and whatever else like children. We live through our entertainment.

It's good to be able to relate to things, but I think growing up in that 80s and 90s environment where everything was suddenly overflowing to the brim with entertainment did tend to tip the scales too far into crazy territory at times. Add in the Internet in the 2000s making everything - even the rants of the worst cretins from IMDb - public, and we've got a lot of work to do in terms of talking about this stuff. If this comes off as a bit finger-wagging in how to talk about movies, well, I just think there are a lot more ways to talk about them without resorting to angry bickering and arguing all the time.

You don't have to resort to cheap ad hominems or assumptions. We are more than our entertainment, more than our tastes. It should be a given that entertainment is art and art is important to society, so we should be able to discuss it in a lot of mature ways that make us better people. I know that sounds sort of hippie-ish, but it's true. Art should make us feel good; not divide us through petty bickering over tastes.

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

The Isla Vista Massacre: Movies and What They Mean

I realize how preposterous it is to have a post this somber just days after I posted a review of a film where trucks took over the world. And I don't want Cinema Freaks to become JUST a vehicle for my own politics and personal opinions. The main thing is still fun and laughs and jokes. Those will continue later, but now it is time for something a bit more somber.

By now, you’ve all heard about the Elliot Rodger mass murder case. Last weekend he massacred a bunch of college-age kids in Isla Vista, California – but the source of much news has been his “manifesto,” which detailed all the ways he would “enact revenge” against every woman who didn’t date him. I won’t bother going too much more into detail on this whole incident because everyone else already has – literally it’s been all over the place. You can’t turn over a stone without finding another opinion on this whole thing and another source of “blame” for the whole incident. People blamed guns, misogyny and (the lack of) mental health care – all the usual targets, which all had varying degrees of truth to them.

One of the more unique points of view I found was that of Washington Post critic Ann Hornaday, who asserted that Rodger’s manifesto and mindset were the result of a life of watching modern Hollywood comedies and romances.

“How many students watch outsized frat-boy fantasies like “Neighbors” and feel, as Rodger did, unjustly shut out of college life that should be full of “sex and fun and pleasure”? How many men, raised on a steady diet of Judd Apatow comedies in which the shlubby arrested adolescent always gets the girl, find that those happy endings constantly elude them and conclude, “It’s not fair”?” she wrote.

Now, I do not proclaim that this tragedy, which claimed the lives of six innocent victims, was the result of movies being watched. Judd Apatow is a talented director who’s made some successful films that reach a wide audience of men and women alike. Also, in general, movies, books and other entertainment are never the direct reason a mass murder happens. Elliot Rodger was criminally insane, and to suggest that this massacre happened JUST BECAUSE he watched a few movies is ludicrous.

BUT … I do think Hornaday’s article is interesting and poses some good points. Not to single out Mr. Apatow or any one film in particular, but her point that modern movies are really only about a small section of the population, only focusing on white mens’ sexual conquests and dating adventures, is a valid one. I would say there is a definite trend in modern American films to portray these dumpy, young guys getting really hot girls. Look at Superbad – it’s a great comedy flick, with a lot of good jokes, but to argue that it does not present a slanted view of real life would be a delusion. That’s just one example.

Face it – women in Hollywood movies are overly sexualized and often presented as trophies for men to “win” at the end of the film. The way modern comedies treat women, you’d think you could be a sloppy, under-achieving loser and somehow still get the hottest chick in school with just a bit of pluck and persistence. Which of course is the whole point – he wants her because she’s hot, nothing else. Never mind the dozens and dozens of less attractive girls – they aren’t given the time of day. Or worse, they are turned into comedic foils. (I fortunately have not seen the latter scenario happen too much.)

Does this mean we can’t enjoy movies like Superbad? Of course not. Plenty of women enjoy the film and plenty of intelligent, self-aware men enjoy it, too. That’s the cincher – even if we do find some brainless enjoyment in commercial summer blockbuster Hollywood films, we should be able to notice the flaws in them, notice the biases and recognize when a film is separate from real life.

Because it’s easy for young people to fall into the trap of watching movies and expecting real life to mirror them instead of the other way around. I was like that as a kid myself. I think lots of people, boys and girls both, tend to look at movies and wonder why they can’t have a picture-perfect romantic relationship, or why they can’t save the day. I believe this has grown over the years that kids have grown up with movies into something like a “main character” complex – we think we’re the main characters in our own lives and expect things to go in a three-act structure, with a climax and a denouement in which we come out on top. This is human nature, but I feel like it has amplified a lot in the 80s and 90s culture of entertainment.

In real life, you don't always get the really hot girl who's ten times more mature than anyone else in the class. In real life, the really hot girls are also insecure and have their own problems like everybody else. In real life, winning those girls doesn't mean your life is suddenly set, and in real life getting into a relationship isn't just a personal victory for you alone to gloat over.

In real life, you'll probably find love in an unexpected place. It will be a girl who may not fit every single check-list of what would be your perfect girlfriend, and you won't fit hers for a perfect boyfriend either, but you'll love one another anyway because it will feel right. That's all the shit Superbad isn't telling you and the other summer romantic comedies aren't telling you. If you're a 17 year old kid like I once was, you may not get that right away, but someday you will.

Elliot Rodger didn't get that, because he was unbalanced to destructive degrees. Elliot Rodger did what he did because he was insane. That’s the bottom line; that’s the end of it. It wasn’t the fault of movies that he spilled blood on the streets of Isla Vista last weekend. However, I feel it important after a tragedy like this to talk about these things anyway. Not to necessarily point blame or put a big old Band-Aid over the situation, but so we can come to a better understanding of the multi-faceted elements of our culture. Opening up a dialogue on social issues is never a bad thing when it gets people thinking outside their normal day-to-day.

Movies do matter. It’s why I have turned so much of my criticism (which can be seen in some of my reviews) in recent years on the level of “what does this do for society?” “What kind of a message is this trying to send, or unconsciously sending?” “What is this saying in-between the lines of what we see?” Because movies can be influential, and powerful – they impact all of us in so many ways.

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

On movie criticism

Let’s talk about movie criticism. Obviously, I critique movies on this blog – sometimes my opinions are overblown and endowed with all kinds of, ahem, “colorful” language and metaphors. That’s just what I do. But beneath it all, I really do try and add in some real analysis. I care about movies. I love films and consider them to be important art just like great works of literature or music.

Most importantly, I think criticizing movies is important. Free, intelligent discourse in which you shouldn’t have to censor your opinion and each party learns about the other’s tastes and maybe takes some new way of looking at things away from the whole thing. Maybe that last bit doesn’t happen very often, but at the least, it’s fun. It’s enjoyable to have a real good, unguarded, no-holds-barred talk about movies.

Which is why it pains me so much whenever I hear the tired arguments against such thinking: “Oh, you’re being too negative.” “Oh, just enjoy it for what it is.” “You can’t enjoy anything, you’re too critical.” The list goes on and more nonsense dribbles out of these peoples’ mouths that I have gotten sick to death of. Frankly, I’m tired of this kind of shit. It’s time to speak up, for once, in favor of critics.

The big thing people love to harp on is the choice of words used. Apparently it’s not okay to say something “sucks.” You have to say you “personally did not care for the film, but completely and utterly understand where everyone else is coming from, and acknowledge the film has points to it that some people, somewhere, might find agreeable in some fashion.” Throw in an extra “IMO” for good measure and you’re set.

What is this shit? Can’t we just be adults and accept that people have different opinions and ways of expressing themselves? Nobody with a rational mind, who functions in society, is actually looking down on you for enjoying a fucking movie. Saying something “sucks” is not secret code for “you are Hitler reincarnated if you like this.” Get over it.

Because, really, that’s where the problem really stems from – not even the words used so much as the sentiment perceived to be behind them. And I kind of get it – when someone hears one of their favorite movies badmouthed, sure, they get defensive; everyone kind of does, even if they don’t acknowledge it. That’s why the heated, no-holds-barred debates I mentioned earlier pop up between friends and acquaintances. It’s healthy to disagree and to talk to other people who disagree. I get that some people don’t like to debate, so fine, you don’t have to.

But all I ask is this: use your brain a little. Just an inch should be enough.

Use your brain and see that this person would have to be incredibly pathetic to actually think less of you for enjoying a certain movie. Realize that when people say something sucks, or that they didn’t like it, IT’S IMPLIED ALREADY that they respect your opinion on a basic, congenial level. They don’t have to explicitly say it like some kind of goddamned Tourette’s syndrome tick, like some kind of awful disclaimer below everything they say! “IMO” (in my opinion, for the laypeople) is self-explanatory, too. It’s not needed. Just cut it out. Of course it’s your opinion; whose else would it be? Do people really think there’s some kind of ultimatum iron-clad list of what opinions are acceptable? If you tell someone you think a movie is good, the “IMO” is pretty much implied inherently.

This is just another product of today’s overtly cheery, fake, PC culture sweeping this country like a plague. God, what a worthless, backwards trend. This shit, piling up miles high now, will send us back into some kind of societal stone age. If not a technological one, then a societal one; a stone age of little to no progress being made in any aspect of human creativity or logic. Because a bunch of limp-wristed pussies were afraid of their feelings getting hurt. Guess what, sometimes your feelings get hurt. Then you get over it and focus on things that actually matter. Things of substance.

But no. In place of actual discussion and mutual respect, we get people calling each other “haters.” Don’t like the way someone expressed a contrary opinion on your favorite thing in the world? They must be a “hater.” It couldn’t possibly be that they just are a different person with a different world-view than you, could it? It’s got to be a “hater.” Ironically, these so-called pundits of some kind of new age of tolerance come off as much less tolerant than those they condemn. Don’t use the wrong words, don’t dislike the wrong things around the wrong people. Bullshit, transparent “rules” set up like invisible fences around what should be the endless, boundless expansion of the mind: human creativity.

Where most of this seems to come from is “fandoms” – i.e. huge droves of people united in alliance to one particular geeky franchise, whether it’s Doctor Who, Harry Potter, The Hunger Games, et cetera. Nothing wrong with any of those things, but the “fandoms” I do have a problem with. The worst of these types just get too dogmatic about it, unable to accept any differing opinions and getting way too emotionally drawn into it. Which means the medium is doing its job; you should get wrapped up in a good story. But when it comes to the point where you’re getting angry whenever anyone happens to not think these things are the greatest in the entire universe…you might want to check yourself into a hospital.

I guess it’s not really the fault of people liking Harry Potter, Doctor Who and the likes so intensely. That just means they have wide appeal and people can really get into them. But when you start actively calling it a “fandom,” and swearing some kind of oath to it, it’s just too fucking much. Fandom denotes a cult-like mentality that ends up robbing any kind of real logic or thought. Mention any kind of disagreement with these people, even mention that you like your own favorites better, and they go insane. Like whatever you want, love whatever you want – but don’t let yourself lose your ability to discern and think.

Whether you agree with me or disagree on some of these points, the upshot and the factual basis of all of this is simple: Movies are released to the public, to be criticized. That’s the whole point. Whether the criticism comes from a standpoint of picking apart little details, or of looking at the movie as an emotional whole, all criticisms are still valid, and when a film is released, it is subjected to whatever analyses and criticisms the larger public wants to use. Some people will have greatly informed criticisms, others just the casual ones of a weekend with nothing else to do but see a movie. Either way, it’s all equally valid and shouldn’t be shat upon because your feelings got hurt.

Our ability to look at films in different ways is what makes films so powerful. We take into account all kinds of things. Some of it is overt and conscious, such as whether or not we found the film initially appealing on the surface. Other times, we apply prejudices and biases – racial, sexual, et cetera. We all come from different walks of life, and we bring our different points of view with us when we watch a movie. That’s what’s so great about films to me, that we all have such differing views. Likewise, some will express their views in strong, robust ways, and others in more laid-back ways – it’s all cool. Just chill the fuck out and accept and that people won’t always act the way you want them to.

So, really, if you are the type of whiny fuckin’ crybaby who applies any of these old clichés (“You’re just too picky,” et. al), you’re pretty much the enemy of art as we know it, and could very well be the downfall of human creativity. These people want a world full of smiling faces without an iota of dissension in the ranks, a festering pot of blandness without a single interesting opinion in the mix. They will pave the road to a world without any great art left, because hey, why bother discerning between good and bad art? Just appreciate it for what it is. Don’t be so picky and judgmental. Just turn your brain off.

I don’t know about you, but that’s starting to sound too close to a Clockwork Orange-type situation for my likings.

But then again, there is one thing we can all agree on…

Kick-Ass 2 is an unholy abomination and should be destroyed at all costs!



Yup, tune in next week for that review!